Fallout 76 is currently one of the most controversial games. Frustrated Fallout fans are overwhelming the title with negative reviews, and even the ratings from professional magazines are not particularly positive.

However, other games have shown that they can still be successful despite similar situations. Can Fallout 76 achieve this as well?

Fallout 76 has not been successful for Bethesda from the start

That’s why it receives mediocre ratings: Gamestar gave it 60 percent, just like PC Gamer. IGN even rated it at only 50 percent for Bethesda’s online game Fallout 76. The prevailing sentiment is that Fallout 76 is currently plagued by bugs and the developers aimed too high. They hoped to appeal to both single-player fans and online players. However, particularly in the single-player area, the title disappoints.

A turnaround is possible: An online game continually evolves. Updates bring significant changes at times. As both Warframe and The Elder Scrolls Online demonstrate, an initially mediocre rated game can become successful over time. However, there are some things to consider:

• The developer studio needs patience – even when criticism pours in and revenues leave much to be desired
• Player feedback must be listened to
• The developers should not be afraid to deviate from their original vision and make larger changes

More on the topic

Fallout 76 made a crucial mistake that is now taking its toll

von Andreas Bertits

Recommended editorial content

At this point you will find external content from YouTube that complements the article.

Show YouTube content

I consent to external content being displayed to me. Personal data can be transmitted to third party platforms. Read more about our privacy policy.

Link to the YouTube content

The potential must be utilized

Why will it be difficult? The first impression of a game is always crucial in determining whether players will stick around in the long term or not. Ratings from magazines still influence the purchasing decisions of many gamers today. Therefore, the release of a game remains very important and can determine success or failure.

A studio as large as Bethesda should refrain from judging the success of an online game like Fallout 76 based on the initial sales figures of a title. Here, Bethesda is somewhat spoiled by Skyrim and Fallout 4, which sold millions of copies right from the start and received high ratings.

Bethesda has the financial resources to stay committed to Fallout 76 in the long run, improve the game, and perhaps even change it. But the willingness to follow through must be present.

Here’s how Fallout 76 can become a brilliant multiplayer game

The potential is there: Reading through the reviews of Fallout 76 reveals plenty of criticism, much of it justified. However, it also mentions that there is potential in Fallout 76. And this potential must now be utilized. To do this, Bethesda needs to focus on the things that players like and develop them consistently. These include:

The group events: Bethesda should introduce more diverse group content that requires teamwork. These events provide variety in the game. They appear unexpectedly and lead players to team up to achieve the common goal. This is a very enjoyable gameplay element that should be expanded.

The general group play: Wandering through the world with friends should be a priority and rewarded. Roaming the post-apocalyptic world with one or more others encourages cooperative play. The social aspect is highlighted, and it is fun to just hang out with other players.

Exploring the game world: Exploring the game area should not only be thrillingly staged but must also provide rewards. Fallout has always thrived on exploring the world and the experiences one could have during it. There is a lot to discover in Fallout 76 as well. Bethesda should offer even more here.

The crafting: New and more powerful items that players can craft are important in most online games. Players want to feel that through hard work they can obtain a truly good weapon or armor. Fallout 76 is already doing a lot right in this regard and should focus even more on it.

Extended base building: Even though base building currently offers too little, it is something that is enjoyable and should be expanded. Managing a large base together, building it up, and defending it can be fun. Fallout 76 is still at the beginning of its potential here. However, this aspect could lead to interesting situations, like sieges.

PvP: The PvP is not well received in the current version. Bethesda should offer more options for combat and also increase the rewards. A division into PvP and PvE servers would also be worth considering. But in general, more incentives should be created to encourage players to engage in PvP. Currently, the system feels too tame and “pointless.”

A good community: The community, which is praised for its helpfulness, must be nurtured. Rewards for good group play and helping other players are important. There are many ways to support the community. An option that could be interesting for Fallout would be the introduction of mods. Although they are planned, Bethesda should not take too long to implement them.

These are the points Bethesda should focus on and expand the things players currently enjoy. This could mean that Fallout 76 would transform away from single-player quests and content that can be done alone and more towards a sort of MMO. Perhaps it would be necessary to increase the number of players per server.

If Bethesda builds it, they will come!

That’s why Bethesda should listen to criticism: Criticism can hurt. However, it is always an opportunity to improve everything. Therefore, it is crucial for Bethesda to read player feedback and the criticism in the reviews of Fallout 76.

Subsequently, the developers should create the game that most fans want to play. If this changes the opinion about Fallout 76, then surely those who quit out of frustration will return. This has worked for other games as well.

As can be seen with The Elder Scrolls Online, successes are still possible even when the launch went poorly. It is important to recognize and exploit the potential of a game to ultimately develop the game that those who have recognized this potential want to play. Will this be easy? No, but it is doable.

Recommended editorial content

At this point you will find external content from YouTube that complements the article.

Show YouTube content

I consent to external content being displayed to me. Personal data can be transmitted to third party platforms. Read more about our privacy policy.

Link to the YouTube content

What do you think? What must Fallout 76 offer to receive better ratings? Discuss in our Fallout group and also get informed on Facebook about news surrounding Fallout 76.

More on the topic

Fallout 76: Bethesda finally fixes 10-year-old FPS issue

von Andreas Bertits

Fallout 76 was officially released on November 14, but has already faced criticism since its announcement. Many reviews are overwhelmingly negative. Our author Benedict absolutely cannot understand that.

Where does the hate come from? Bethesda announced Fallout 76 as the first multiplayer Fallout game. Fallout 76 is about the survivors from Vault 76, and all human characters are controlled by players.

Many critiques have already bothered the community before release:

• Fallout 76 has open and constant PvP – can that work well?
• A story without human NPCs bothers single-player fans.
• Does a multiplayer destroy the immersion of a “real Fallout” that Fallout 76 wants to be?

The bad mood escalated by the release, culminating recently in catastrophic ratings on Metacritic and other platforms. According to the players, expectations were raised that Fallout 76 would be a great experience for single-player fans.

However, I see it differently and am excited about Fallout 76. Unfortunately, I constantly have to hear how stupid I am for thinking this.

A game I finally want to play again

Since the first day of the Beta for PC, I have been playing Fallout 76. I had to spend hours in the settings and saw some bugs; however, I do not regret playing.

It may be an unpopular opinion, but I like Fallout 76.

I have also enjoyed Fallout before. Dystopian settings are always cool, and Fallout implements them as well as hardly any other game series. That I would be dealing with Fallout 76 was already clear to me when it was announced at E3.

Shortly before the servers were shut down for the first time after the beta, I found that I wanted to keep playing. Fallout 76 captured me quite quickly.

What makes Fallout so fun to play?

After character creation, the game begins in Vault 76 with an introduction on how Fallout actually works. There is the first basic equipment and witty comments from Mr. Handies that still hover around the vault.

The first quest also comes quite early. The overseer’s recordings urge players to follow her path and find out what happened to her. The entire story has persisted through my over 20 hours of gameplay and continues to branch out.

I can hardly get to the main story

Whenever I am on my way to the next checkpoint, I find an interesting location that I want to explore first and where there is more to do.

I had the same “problem” in every previous Fallout as well. I can’t manage to do what I set out to do. But that’s not a bad thing; after all, I want to explore the world and play the game, not just follow a single story.

The world is fantastic

Fallout 76 offers many places where you can easily get lost. Many may complain about the graphics, but I find the level of detail hidden in the world magnificent.

It starts with many of the enemies being “classic Fallout enemies” like Super Mutants and Deathclaws. However, there are also monsters that have been directly transferred from the legends and myths of West Virginia into the game.

Some of these legendary monsters even have legends in the game that I have partly discovered and partly still need to find. There is a whole museum dedicated to the Mothman, with which players have already taken selfies.

Additionally, the spirit of exploration is rewarded. I have already found several locations that are not just “on the way.” One rewarded me with a wonderfully beautiful view over West Virginia. Another shows the space exploration attempts of two plush bears with a stuffed monkey.

Crafting is fun

More than in any other Fallout before, Fallout 76 has a building and crafting system that is very relevant to the game. Each player can build and even easily move their own camp almost anywhere.

Camps can simply be objects placed in the wilderness or a small house that players can plan and build. There are workshops for groups that can be captured and expanded, providing more resources, including hard-to-find, rare materials.

At several crafting stations, all sorts of items can be crafted with the materials collected. There are stations for:

• Weapons
• Armor
• Chems
• Ammunition and explosives
• Power Armor
• Food

Equipping armor and modifying weapons to fit my playstyle takes a large part of my playtime. I enjoy tinkering and trying to outfit my weapons to be ideal for me.

Group and solo – both are not a problem

I mostly play Fallout 76 alone. This way, I can take the time to explore everything I find. I listen to holotapes or read terminals for more story.

I still have some friends who play less and whom I can help. If they have problems, I check in and help with quests or provide them with my old Power Armors, which are upgrades for them.

But group play is also interesting. In groups, you gain more experience and it is logically easier to tackle tougher enemies than alone. However, I wouldn’t say it comes down to “group or solo.” Fallout 76 simply offers content for both.

Is there also something negative?

Despite all the praise, Fallout 76 is not “the best game ever.” Even in beta, there were numerous bugs, some of which caused serious issues. Technical problems like impossible uninstallation do not make it any better. Especially annoying are features that do not seem fully thought out.

PvP is “just there”: Many players initially had “fear” of PvP. They feared that griefers would ruin their fun. However, Bethesda introduced special mechanics to prevent griefing in Fallout 76. The entire PvP is generally not a cause for panic, as it simply has little impact.

I have had two experiences with PvP so far:

• The first time, I hunted a player with a bounty who had apparently annoyed many players. However, too many players argued over his bounty, and he was taken down by several players shortly after.
• The second encounter was alone with a high-level wanted person. I wanted to collect his bounty. However, since we were both well-equipped, after about 400 shots of ammunition and 10 Stimpaks on both sides, we nodded friendly to each other and went our separate ways. Killing was simply not possible.

This kind of PvP is not a real part of the world. It happens too rarely and has no real justification for existence. It could have been kept out or solved differently.

Too few options: Missing settings in the game are particularly annoying. On PC, important graphics options like field of view, depth, or an option for ultrawide monitors are missing.

PC gamers suffer significant losses in gameplay quality and sometimes even suffer from nausea and motion sickness. Settings can only be adjusted by changing the .ini files, which could potentially lead to penalties from Bethesda.

All this is unfortunate, but it could still be improved after criticism in the future. After all, Fallout 76 is supposed to be worked on for a while. These are also more like “cosmetic flaws.”

I don’t understand the negative voices

As someone who has already invested some hours into the game, I cannot understand where the hate comes from. Fallout 76 is solid, fun, and captivates me like no game in a while.

Justified criticism vs. baseless hate: I understand critics who say that the negative aspects annoy them and that they want to wait until they are fixed. After all, Fallout 76 is a full-price game, and one can certainly set higher standards.

What I completely disagree with are statements about the lack of endgame content, long-term motivation, and the absence of NPCs. Especially the point about NPCs seems like a pretext for unfounded hatred.

I asked several fans who made this argument if they could name NPCs from the predecessors. Very few answers came. The story in the previous parts is also largely conveyed through holotapes and terminals.

Furthermore, only strictly human NPCs are missing in Fallout 76. Robots are still around and distribute quests. And when thinking of Allistair Tenpenny from Fallout 3, one of the few people remembered, many robots are more human than some humans…

The endgame is great: I find it hard to understand that people already feared before the game’s release that they would have nothing to do at the end. The first hardcore players have already launched the first atomic bomb. However, this only provided a glimpse into what can come.

Those who actually reach the “endgame” of Fallout 76 can utilize atom bombs to increase difficulty. Insanely tough bosses that require lengthy battles provide ever better loot.

While this sounds like grind, in order to get there, a large part of the story must be played first. And just the side content of Fallout 76 already adds up to 150 hours of gameplay. I don’t know who that can say is “not enough endgame”.

I like Fallout 76 and that will remain so

Many players have valid criticism of Fallout 76. I also find small bugs or annoying errors like crashes that make me grind my teeth here and there. But I live with these little evils.

I enjoy playing Fallout 76 in between for small events. When I have time, I engage in quests to explore more of the world. Aside from minor control issues, there’s nothing that bothers me more often. On the contrary, I enjoy finding places where I can truly enjoy the game, take in the surroundings, or test new weapons.

If that all isn’t enough, then feel free to spit at me for my opinion. Because that’s the feeling I have right now whenever I express that I like Fallout 76.

What do you think? Are you with me or do you not like Fallout 76? Write a comment or discuss in our Fallout group. On Facebook you can find more great specials and hot news about Fallout 76.

More on the topic

Fallout 76: I wish I had known these 10 tips beforehand

von Tarek Zehrer