I finally understand why fans of Lord of the Rings hate Rings of Power

Ringe der Macht Staffel 3 entschuldigung

MeinMMO editor Sophia Weiß boasted about how little she cares about the opinions of the outraged Tolkien fans regarding the Rings of Power. However, after the first six new episodes, she is slowly starting to understand the hate.

My mindset for the third season of Rings of Power was basically: Finally, Sauron is getting serious with Middle-earth, and we are back on track with the major plot points we know from the Second Age. I was really looking forward to it. Especially since the last season ended I took a deep dive and expanded my Tolkien knowledge:

A post on social media introduced me to the character Glorfindel and I fell into a rabbit hole of Middle-earth wikis and YouTube videos because Glorfindel does not appear in the movie trilogy. In 2026, I also absorbed the audiobook of the Silmarillion.

So I thought that with all the newly gained expertise about the various ages and characters, I would be perfectly prepared for the new season. That I would recognize every Easter egg and be enjoying the series even more.

Instead, there are scenes that are having my toenails curling. I finally understand why Tolkien fans hate Rings of Power.

Start video
The Rings of Power shows a powerful Balrog in the official trailer for Season 3

It doesn’t make any sense!

Attention, spoilers! The following contains information about the content of season 3 of Rings of Power. Those who want to watch unspoiled should not read further.

I enjoyed the first two seasons of Rings of Power while being blissfully ignorant. Our editor Niko Hernes writes that he thinks the world too digital, but I think its beautiful. In The Lord of the Rings, Middle-earth quickly becomes very dark – in terms of the plot, as well as visually. Especially seeing the elven settlements or Númenor at its height? I love it.

I sat down for episode one with huge enthusiasm, and right at the start, there was that great flashback to the now-lost realm of the Grey Elves: Doriath. Celeborn meets Galadriel – the Silmarillion does not specify how exactly that happened, only the location. So I celebrated that at first.

Then suddenly they both surveyed a hill that will likely one day become Lothlórien. My brain immediately skipped like a record because: Galadriel and Celeborn did not leave Doriath and its surroundings – at least in the First Age.

There is so much that just doesn’t fit – my head desperately tried to reconcile the location of Doriath with that of Lothlórien and the known whereabouts of Galadriel and Celeborn. But nothing I could think of would plausibly explain this scene. Except perhaps: The showrunners took the easy way out.

But then more things kept coming:

  • Why is the wood elf Arondir commanding high elven soldiers?
  • If Arondir is a wood elf, he does not just have friends in the Greenwood, but it is his home.
  • Why does Eru Ilúvatar speak personally with Gandalf, and why does it have to be staged in a way that reminiscent of the biblical Moses story?
  • High King Gil-Galad visits Númenor – that’s fine – but why do he and Elrond walk through the city without a guard?
  • Sauron was a pupil of Aulë, the Valar of smithing – if anyone should know how to forge the One Ring, it should be Sauron. Why does he have so much trouble with it?

Anyone who has read the Silmarillion once more and perhaps has even digested all the other Middle-earth materials will probably notice even more.

For me, there are also storytelling points that I find difficult. For example, Theo’s 180-degree turn. Sure, he has probably been enslaved by Kemen for 5 years. But we don’t see that happen.

Or the fact that after two seasons as a traitor, Isildur’s sister Eärien is suddenly a double agent and gets a really cool plot. But within the same episode, she gets exposed and chooses to die by her own hand. I would have liked to see much more of her in this role. Now I feel like she was a loose story end that needed to be tidied up before the Númenor story starts to align more closely with the source material.

And what is actually happening with the war between the Elves and Sauron? We hear about it. But we don’t see it. I don’t feel like the elves are threatened at all.

I do have to confess: I love what they are doing with Celeborn. Jamie Campbell Bower is perfect, and I can’t get enough of him in the role. Whether it’s romantic scenes with Galadriel or Celeborn antagonizing Sauron to perfection.

The mix of romantic fantasy, torture porn, and mindgames too does excite the fangirl within me. But at the same time, that’s not really what editor me expected from Rings of Power. This isn’t a plot that I foresaw with regard to the first two seasons. Even if Bi-King Sauron is certainly no surprise. I always thought that Rings of Power was too clean for a fanfiction like plot.

It’s cringe, but not everything is bad

As much as I finally feel what other Tolkien fans have been saying since season one, there are still things I currently enjoy. Jamie Campbell Bower as Celeborn is just perfection. There’s no arguing about that.

I also enjoy that the storylines in Númenor are now closer to the source again. We can debate whether healing Míriel was a good decision or not, but the marriage plot with Pharazôn has been lifted directly from Tolkien.

For the turncoat orc Marnûkh, I don’t know of any source, but his motives are drawn directly from the events of previous seasons. Moreover, the character gives more depth and background to the armies of Mordor, often characterized as a black mass of henchmen.

Rings of Power has already hinted in the first seasons that the Orcs are corrupted Elves – Adar even directly addresses this. An Orc who even writes poetry solidifies this origin for me. Although, of course, I know that Tolkien himself deviated from it. However, with my current knowledge, this makes sense.

As before, I still celebrate the dwarves in season three. Durin IV does not want to share the seven rings of the dwarves, and his own brother turns against him. I do think the affair between Thrain and Disa is kind of contrifed, since Disa has always been characterized as headstrong yet loyal. But everyone makes mistakes, and it provides a good story. Finally, Durin and Disa Junior have faces – please let’s see more of them!

Elrond in Númenor is also a different caliber. I wonder if he realizes that many of the people around him are descendants of Elros. But may I wish for more Elrond and Durin IV in season four? They make a great duo.

Tolkien fans, I’m sorry.

At this point, I also want to say what I think is overdue: I approached season 3 very arrogantly and said that I don’t care what the Tolkien purists say.

The Tolkien purists are right in many places. I can now understand that and want to apologize for my audacity. You are right.

If I look back at seasons one and two now, I will probably also notice a lot of problems. Gandalf’s story pops immediately to mind. Nevertheless, I will continue to watch Rings of Power.

Yes, I will probably still find my toenails curling. But you can always trim them. As long as I don’t have to pull my hair out, I will stay on board. Above all, I now have Celeborn alongside Elrond, as characters whose development I want to continue to follow. Let’s hope that he does not disappear again in the last two episodes. He must eventually take over Lothlórien with Galadriel after all.

… there I could get angry again: Lothlórien is not built by Galadriel and Celeborn but is its own elven realm. It just doesn’t fit together at all!

Enough anger for one day.

Also something that, I believe, is not explicitly stated in the source is the specific origin of the Ringwraiths. Rings of Power gives them faces and stories. I like that. If you want to know more about who or what the Nazgûl are, to whom the now shown kings will later become, we have the answer for you here: The Rings of Power: Who are the Nazgûl and why do they serve Sauron?