Former speedrun star Narcissa “NarcissaWright” Wright has had a troubling time on Twitch: After a temporary ban, she threatened to shoot people at the Twitch headquarters. As a result, she received a permanent ban from Twitch: But now the streaming service shows mercy.
Warning: This article deals with the topics of rampage and suicidal thoughts. If such topics are uncomfortable for you, then you should avoid this article.
Who is the streamer?
- Narcissa Wright was known as “CosmoWright” at just 17 years old for speedruns in Zelda. From 2006 to 2015, she captivated tens of thousands on screen and had great success in gaming for that time. In 2014, she completed “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” in 16 minutes and 10 seconds.
- In November 2015, Wright came out as a transgender woman and began her transition. On Twitch, she distanced herself from speedrunning. In 2018, her channel, which had a few hundred viewers left, was banned for years.
- In 2022, she made headlines again, but not with her skills in Zelda, but with her presence on social media.
Streamer Gets Ban Because Troll Sets Her Up – Goes Completely Crazy
What led to the permanent ban on Twitch? The streamer was back on Twitch after 4 years and mistakenly displayed an offensive image during one of her first new streams. For that, she received a temporary ban from Twitch. A troll had set her up and made her show the image. Trolling like this is something trolls do sometimes – something similar happened to the streamer Forsen.
But the streamer did not cope at all with the temporary ban from Twitch. She posted completely insane things on Twitter. The worst tweet came on March 22. There she said she wanted to kill herself and shoot people at the Twitch headquarters.
This resulted in a permanent ban. The ban by Twitch had to happen:
- “Suicide” is a highly sensitive topic on Twitch – streamers have been permanently banned even for “self-injury” and that was only about a streamer regularly hitting a keyboard over his head.
- “Rampages” are one of the few topics that fall in the same “ban” league as suicide. In 2018 a rampage at the YouTube headquarters made worldwide headlines. In the USA, such “mass shootings” are a real threat.
The streamer therefore received a permanent ban from Twitch, which can only be overturned by a successful appeal.
Twitch Turns Permanent Ban into Monthly Ban
This is the new development: The streamer showed on March 29 the message from Twitch that her permanent ban has been converted into a ban that expires after 22 days. She will therefore receive a “one-month” ban.
Such a ban was also received by MontanaBlack when he made Neanderthal shouts against women.
Twitch says the permanent ban was appropriate in itself. But considering the details of the case and the fact that she showed remorse, Twitch decided to lighten the punishment.
What’s behind this: This is a difficult case for Twitch. The streamer’s tweet in itself is already a double reason for a permanent ban:
- The threat of violence against oneself or others is a red line that must not be crossed.
- This could create a dangerous precedent if leniency is shown here.
- If there is no permanent ban for this, then when should there be one?
On the other hand, the threat was not made on Twitch but on another platform and was marked with a “hahahaah!!” Nevertheless, the streamer appears unstable on Twitter – she refers to it as “mentally flexible.”
From her perspective, she was punished for sharing her thoughts in a moment – but had no intention of implementing them in any way. She emphasizes she doesn’t even own a gun.
In the tweets after the permanent ban, the streamer alternates between extreme feelings:
- On one hand, she feels unjustly treated and believes she lives in a cold nightmare world where her last possibility to interact with people has been taken away.
- She emphasizes that she is going through an extremely difficult phase right now and has been punished for something she did not intend to do, and is being “destroyed and de-platformed” here.
- Time and again she says how much she needs streaming for herself and that she misses streaming. Alternatives to Twitch don’t really exist.
It seems that Twitch did not isolate the statement but considered everything around it and concluded that Wright’s behavior does not justify a permanent ban.
Twitch has repeatedly emphasized that they always take context into account when it comes to bans. This, however, leads to a permanent discussion about the often strange-seeming ban policy of the streaming service:
Twitch CEO explains: Why some get banned and others don’t – The thorny issue
